MacNoob

May you have a blessed holiday!

October 14^th, 2011. Mark that date. I believe history will treat it as the day we began using speech to interact with our computers. It is the day Apple released the iPhone 4S with Siri, the automated assistant built exclusively into the 4S. Before I elaborate, a brief disclaimer. I am an unapologetic geek and a huge Apple fan. Having said that, I honestly believe I’m being objective when I predict Siri will be viewed as a transformative technological innovation.

Apple describes Siri as an “intelligent assistant”. After using it for just three weeks, I believe their description is accurate. We’ve been able to speak commands in varying degrees to our computers, cars and smartphones for some time now. So, what’s new and/or different about Siri? A lot. First, Siri doesn’t restrict what you ask or tell it. For example, my car is a 2006 model and uses voice input to dial phone numbers, set the A/C temperature or change the radio station, but I have to remember the exact commands and speak them clearly (and in just the right sequence) for the system to work. Not much intelligence there. Siri, by contrast really seems to understand the English language. For instance, I can ask Siri to “Tell Katherine dinner is at 6” and it is smart enough to know I want to send Katherine a text message. Siri responds, “I have created a new text message for Katherine” then displays “Dinner is at 6″ and asks, “Would you like me to send it?” I simply say yes and the text message is sent. Not extremely groundbreaking, I agree, but if instead of saying “yes” I said “Change that to 5:30“, Siri is smart enough to change the text message to read, “Dinner is at 5:30″! That’s my second point. The artificial intelligence built into Siri understands commands contextually. Siri knew I wanted to change dinnertime. It didn’t try to send a text message to “5-3-0″ or create a new message, “Change that to 5:30″. It responded like a human would. This is far beyond any voice recognition system I have ever used and light years ahead of what the Germans programmed into my sedan.

Siri also remembers relationships. I told Siri, “Ann Kelley is my wife” and after a confirmation, Siri remembers it forever or until I change it (I really hope I never have a reason to do that!). The same goes for all my daughters. So, when I ask Siri, “Tell the family my flight arrives at 8“, it creates an MMS to my wife and three daughters, “My flight arrives at 8″ and sends the message to all four. The same works with other relationships or nicknames like “boss”, “secretary”, “butt-head” and “landlord” or just about anything you can think of. Along the same vein, with a free iPhone app called “Find My Friends” I can ask Siri “Where is Katherine?” and up pops a map with the location of Katherine’s iPhone. I naturally assume that’s where Katherine is because if she gets more than a few feet away from her iPhone she has nervous tremors.

Siri is also very valuable when you travel. I was in Corpus Christi last week for business and didn’t know my way around too well. When I got hungry one evening I asked Siri, “What’s a good Mexican restaurant nearby?” and a list of Tex-Mex joints popped up on the screen complete with distance to, ratings and price ranges. Since I asked for a “good” restaurant the results were sorted by rating. Out of curiosity I rephrased the question to “Where is the closest Mexican restaurant?” and the same list appeared, but this time it was sorted from nearest to farthest. After dinner I asked Siri “How do I get back to the Hampton Inn?” and a map popped up on the screen with pushpins showing my current location and the hotel plus two different highlighted routes to get me there. While I was driving back to the hotel I received a text message. I asked Siri, “Read the text message” and Siri replied telling me it was from Robert and read the message, “When would you like to meet tomorrow?” I told Siri, “Reply 8:30 AM” and Siri sent “8:30 AM” in response and my hands never left the steering wheel. Next I asked Siri to “Create an appointment with Robert for 8:30 tomorrow morning.” and after a confirmation the new appointment was added to my calendar. When I was ready for bed back at the hotel I asked Siri to “Wake me up at 6:30“. Siri responded “I have set an alarm for 6:30 AM, Joe“, and did so. (Siri will refer to you using any name you wish. I tried “Your Highness” first, but that just sounded weird.)

Another thing that makes Siri so amazing is there’s no training involved. I didn’t have to memorize a list of things I could ask (like my car system made me do) and I didn’t have to train Siri to recognize my voice like Microsoft’s voice recognition software. I just picked up my iPhone and started using it. Does it make mistakes? Sure. Nothing’s perfect, but it is astounding just how accurate it is. Unscientifically, I’d estimate Siri gets it right about 75% of the time and the more I use it, the better it gets. I think that’s because I’m getting better at communicating with it and it is learning what I expect. I’m also learning that a good network connection is absolutely essential. Since Siri’s brains reside on Apple’s servers in North Carolina, a good 3G or Wi-Fi signal is necessary to send your requests. The only thing happening on the iPhone itself is the recording of your voice. That recording is then sent to Apple’s servers where those really powerful computers interpret your recording and formulate a response. That’s why Siri is so effective. With a good network connection Siri is also very fast. Even the most complex request takes only a second or two. Siri even understands Texan quite well (something I’ve found to be problematic with other voice recognition software). My wife jokes that I sound like I’m talking to a girlfriend when I converse with Siri (who’s automated female voice is just short of human). That’s the way it is, like a very natural conversation.

Currently, Siri is officially “beta” software. That’s geek speak for “not fully baked”. It also means that in addition to admitting bugs, Apple is just getting started with this technology. Some tech pundits predict Siri will be implemented on all Apple devices in the near future. I tend to agree. Given how well Siri works today, it’s bound to be completely astonishing a couple of years from now. Don’t misunderstand, we’re still a long way from HAL 9000, but Siri is the first voice recognition application I’ve ever been tempted to say “Thank you” to.

Tweet

I never thought I’d hear myself utter those words. I’ve probably been one of AgileBits’ most boisterous proponents, recommending 1Password for the past four years in every medium I possess. This blog, our MacTexan podcast and the MacNoob blog have all had posts and segments dedicated to 1Password evangalism. With the Mac App Store release of version 3.9 I must rebut myself.

When I got the email notification from AgileBits announcing the release of version 3.9, I was all too happy to spend twenty bucks for the privilege of downloading 1Password from the MAS. While there are few visible changes from version 3.8.5 (the most recent non-MAS version), the promise of a free upgrade to version 4 and automatic updating was more than enough reason for me to spring. Turns out, IT WAS A BAD IDEA! Version 3.9 is a giant step backwards from the usual error-free, reliable releases I’ve come to expect from the 1P guys. After installation I soon realized I was working from a very dated keychain database and the Dropbox support, while advertized, wouldn’t work. When I tried to point version 3.9 to my keychain file stored in my Dropbox folder, the button for doing so was greyed out and nothing I did would change that. I spent countless hours fighting failed imports and corrupted databases before finally surrendering and reverting to the 3.8.5 version stored in a Time Machine backup. In the process, the 1P data on each of my iOS devices was FUBAR. Thankfully, Dropbox and Time Machine saved my bacon but I still don’t have the new MAS version of 1Password I paid for. If you want my advice, DON’T UPGRADE YET.

The greatly anticipated Amazon tablet (dubbed the Kindle) is expected to hit the streets before the Christmas buying season begins. M. G. Siegler at TechCrunch says he’s played with the new device and reports the new 7” tablet will be available sometime in October. So what makes the new Kindle different from every other Android tablet and why will it be the first to challenge the iPad?

Content, content and more content.

Unlike every other iPad “competitor”, Amazon has the content infrastructure in place to provide buyers with a true “end-to-end” experience. It’s something the Samsungs and Motorolas of the world don’t have and can’t provide. This complete solution including great hardware, a sound and user-friendly operating system and a convenient, well-stocked content market is what has made the iPad so successful (with over 80% market share). Take away any one of these three ingredients and the iPad would be no more successful than the HP TouchPad. Motorola and Samsung both make great hardware and the latest Android build, while no iOS is arguably good enough, but users wanting movies, music and more apps for their device are forced to navigate through a hodgepodge of content providers with no unified method of getting apps and media purchased and installed. Amazon is the only company that seems to get it. Their MP3 store has been on-line for years now and Amazon Prime customers recently got access to a wealth of movies. Additionally, according to Mr. Siegler, Amazon plans to open their own app store. If there’s one thing Amazon does better than anyone, it’s operate an on-line market. The Android Marketplace won’t even work on the new Kindle’s forked Android version that Amazon is customizing specifically for this device. Word is, it won’t look like any Android version we’ve seen.

So, it looks like Apple is finally going to have some competition in the tablet space. I say GREAT! Competition drives lower prices and innovation and so far, no one has mounted a serious challenge to the iPad. Amazon certainly has the chops to do it.

Undo "natural" scrolling

The more I use OS X Lion, the better I like it.  The only feature I’ve had trouble with is the new scrolling behavior. I gave it a week to “sink in”, but I just couldn’t get used to it.  If you’re having the same problem there’s a simple method for turning it off.  Simply open System Preferences and select “Trackpad”.  When visible, select “Scroll & Zoom” from the top toggle buttons.  Uncheck the top checkbox (as shown) and scrolling will return to the way it’s been for the past twenty years or so.  I don’t know what Apple is up to with this change. Maybe they’re training us for some future super duper changes they have in store. I’ll worry about it then. For now, I’m back to scrolling things the way I’m used to.